SEO vs. Social Engagement: Which Strategy Grows Your Audience Faster?

▶︎

In the world of digital marketing, two primary strategies compete for attention: SEO (Search Engine Optimization) and Social Engagement. One focuses on discoverability and technical optimization, while the other builds human connection and shareability. Which should you focus on? And can these two approaches work together to accelerate growth? Let’s explore both strategies and how they might complement each other for optimal results.

SEO vs Social Connection

For those of us who think in both strategic and creative terms, this debate feels like a battle between the left and right brain. SEO is all about logic and formulas—follow the steps, and you’ll get results. Social engagement, on the other hand, relies on creativity, connection, and the unpredictable nature of “social” media.

Take my website, Designing the Row. The most visited page is an old blog post titled 16 Instagram Ideas for Musicians. Although it follows SEO best practices, that alone doesn’t guarantee success, especially with social media’s constant evolution.

My takeaway? While you should cover the SEO basics, the main focus should be on creating engaging content. Let’s dive into the specifics!

SEO Practices

SEO, or Search Engine Optimization, is the process of making your online content more accessible to search engines. Key SEO practices include keyword research, using clear display names, writing detailed bios, and using consistent links. These elements help search engines—and audiences—understand your content and connect with it more easily.

I emphasize having a well-optimized username, display name, and bio. For instance, my Instagram display name reads "Designing the Row | Squarespace Website Design," giving people a clear understanding of what I offer. A quick win? Make sure all your social profiles are consistent and that your links work!

Social Engagement

On the other side, social engagement involves reaching people on a human level, creating posts that people want to engage with. In my classes, I’ve seen students analyze successful music artists’ accounts with over 50,000 followers. Many popular creators don’t use SEO best practices but instead focus on authentic, repetitive, and emotionally resonant content.

For example, artist Ryan Nealon repeats song snippets with different perspectives—vulnerability, authenticity, and fan engagement. His strategy proves that engagement-focused content can reach a wide audience without relying on SEO tricks.

Conclusion

Both SEO and social engagement have unique strengths. SEO builds lasting relevance, while engagement-focused content offers immediate growth potential. My recommendation is to start by optimizing your profiles for SEO and then focus on creating engaging, relatable content that encourages interaction.

Are you planning to update your social media strategy after reading this post and watching the video? Let me know in the comments!